TPT among the top‑performing DC default funds of the past decade
In this article, Philip Smith examines newly published 10‑year performance data and explains why long‑term outcomes — not scale alone — should define quality in DC pensions.
Corporate Adviser has published 10-year performance data for DC master trust default funds using CAPAdata, its independently compiled dataset. The range of outcomes is hard to ignore.
Over the 10 years to December 2025, the top-performing fund returned 232%. The lowest returned 88%. I am proud to say that TPT ranked third in that table, generating significantly above-average returns for our members.
That is not a marginal difference. It is the kind of gap that should make the whole market stop and think.
For a long time, scale and low cost have carried a built-in assumption of safety. Big feels credible. Cheap feels efficient. Both are easy to defend. But member outcomes are what matter, and outcomes like these are a reminder that size and price do not, on their own, define value.
What appears to matter more is harder to reduce to a headline number: the quality of investment strategy, the strength of governance, the discipline of oversight, and the ability to execute consistently over time.
That is why this matters so much in the current debate. Consolidation may well have benefits. But if the Government continues treating scale itself as proof of quality, it risks learning the wrong lesson.
Australia has been grappling with the same question. Research from the Conexus Institute argues that both large and small funds can succeed if they are designed well, and warns against pursuing size for its own sake.
The right question is not: how big is the scheme?
It is: how well is it run, and what outcomes is it actually delivering for members?
The more the market is forced to answer that question with real performance data, the better.
Scale is not a strategy. Outcomes are.
Related news & insights
-
DB Consolidation Mythbuster
Our Defined Benefit Consolidation Mythbuster draws out the most common misconceptions about consolidation to help you make informed decisions about the future of your scheme and the benefits it may bring to you and your members. -
Four independent advisers appointed to support Trustee Board of TPT’s new run-on DB Superfund
The Trustee Board has appointed Gowling WLG to provide legal advice and Mercer as scheme actuary. In addition, LCP will provide independent investment oversight and EY will be the Superfund’s risk advisor. -
TPT hires new Head of Consultant Relations
A central part of Katherine's brief will be to identify and build relationships with employee benefit consultants (EBCs) across the full spectrum of consolidation vehicles TPT offers. -
TPTIM signs up first external fiduciary management client
Dalriada Trustees Limited has become a fiduciary management client on behalf of Paradigm Housing’s Defined Benefit (DB) Pension Plan. This marks the first time TPTIM has co-signed a Fiduciary Management Agreement with an external trustee.